Skip to content
IlmHub Questions & Answers

Questions & Answers under the supervision of Mufti Faisal al-Mahmudi

Close Menu

Is Salah accepted if masjid starts salah at makrooh time?

600 viewsSalahjamua jumma salah

Assalam alaikum muftisahab,

I offered jumma in a masjid where Salah started in makrooh time, the masjid clock was also showing as prohibited for prayers, will Salah be accepted?

Bismillahi Ta’ala

Walaikum Assalam Warahmatullah

Your question is about Jumu’a time. The beginning time for Jumu’a Salah is same as Dhuhr Salah, i.e right after Zawal.

Moreover, it is a condition for the validity of Jumu’a that the Khutbah be rendered in the Jumu’a time as well. The minimum requirement of khutba must be fulfilled after zawal time has finished.

The “prohibited” time normally displayed on the Masjid Clocks covers a considerable time beyond actual zawal. On average the sun can move from its position in totality in approximately ~3 to ~5 minutes. Salah Times calculators normally keep a delay of 2-3 minutes for safety and accommodation for any refraction as well. For your purpose this entry time is suitable to assume the correct time for Jumu’a entry.

Hence, check your Salah Calendar to see the entry time of Dhuhr, and if the Khutba is conducted after this time, then despite the clock mentioning “prohibited time”, the Jumu’a will be valid.

However, if they start their khutba before this entry time, then atleast sufficient time of khutba’s integrals (Tasbeeh, Tahmeed etc) must be within its valid entry time to barely fulfil the technical validity for khutba, and hence for Jumu’a Salah.

Wallahu A’lam

And Allah Ta’āla Knows Best
Mufti Faisal al-Mahmudi

Categories

  • General (Misc)
    265 Questions
  • Salah
    56 Questions
  • Ramadan
    54 Questions
  • Zakat
    45 Questions
  • Hajj and Umrah
    12 Questions
  • Tahara (Wudhu and Salah)
    10 Questions
  • Shawwal
    5 Questions
  • I'tikaaf
    3 Questions

Questions

Child tastes nose mucus – will it invalidate fast?

Tasted gravy from suhoor on lips while fasting

Local charity organization to decide whom to give zakat

Dental procedures – do they nullify fasts?

Calculating the value of gold

© Copyright 2023. Designed and Developed by IlmHub