Skip to content
IlmHub Questions & Answers

Questions & Answers under the supervision of Mufti Faisal al-Mahmudi

Close Menu

Will such milk be halal if brewers spent grain is used to make milk?

445 viewsGeneral (Misc)halal haram leather vegan milk

As per this link brewers spent grain is being transformed into vegan milk or even leather.

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20250206-how-brewers-spent-grain-is-being-turned-into-vegan-barley-milk-leather-and-cakes

  1. Would such milk be halal suitable for consumption?
  2. Would the leather made from this process be pure?

Bismillahi Ta’ala

Walaikum Assalam Warahmatullah,

At the outset, we establish the shar‘ī distinction between khamr and synthetic alcohol. Khamr refers specifically to fermented substances derived from dates or grapes. In contrast, alcohol from all other sources is classified as non-khamr (or, for our terminology, synthetic alcohol).

Secondly, we note the primary shar‘ī rulings derived from the Qur’an concerning khamr:

a. It is harām for consumption, even in small quantities.
b. It is najis (impure) with a status of ghalīẓa (severe impurity).

However, non-khamr alcohol is governed by different rulings:

a. It is harām for consumption only when:
– It is used for intoxication.
– It is consumed in vain or for futile purposes.
– It is consumed in a quantity that leads to intoxication.
b. It is not considered najis (impure).

For further details on the use of alcohol in products, you may refer to our blog posts: [ https://ilmhub.com/?s=alcohol ].

BSG: Brewer’s Spent Grain

During brewing, malted barley is mashed to extract fermentable sugars, leaving behind the solid residue known as Brewer’s Spent Grain (BSG). This material does not undergo fermentation; rather, it consists of the leftover grain husks and other components after the sugars have been extracted.

Thus:

1. Milk made from BSG mulch is Halal Suitable since the grains are not fermented and do not contain alcohol. Even if fermentation were to occur, it would not be a concern, as it would fall under non-khamr.

2. Leather made from BSG mulch follows the non-khamr ruling regarding purity. Therefore, such leather is Halal Suitable for use.

Wallahu A’lam

And Allah Ta’āla Knows Best
Mufti Faisal al-Mahmudi

Categories

  • General (Misc)
    265 Questions
  • Salah
    56 Questions
  • Ramadan
    55 Questions
  • Zakat
    46 Questions
  • Hajj and Umrah
    12 Questions
  • Tahara (Wudhu and Salah)
    10 Questions
  • Shawwal
    5 Questions
  • I'tikaaf
    3 Questions

Questions

Missing first sitting of a Isha’ prayer and subsequent Taraweeh

Zakat on a plot which was to be sold but didn’t sell

Is it permissible for 70 years old to skip fasts in lieu of pay fidya?

Salah timings different in Islamic Apps vs local masjid – whom to follow in Ramadan?

Fajr in different Time Tables and my Suhoor

© Copyright 2023. Designed and Developed by IlmHub